Start from the day the change went live
Measure from the day the new version was on the page, not the day the work was done. A release can wait in a queue, and a cache can serve the old page for days.
Change one thing on a page at a time. A second change inside the window mixes two effects, and neither can be read on its own.
Compare 28 days after with the 28 days before
Take two windows of the same length, so that each holds the same weekdays. 28 days is four full weeks, long enough for most pages to collect clicks worth reading.
Search Console's final data trails by about 3 days. So the 28 days after a change can be read 31 days after it went live, and not before.
Set the page against the whole site
A page whose clicks rose by a tenth while the whole site rose by a fifth did worse than the site. Compare the change of the page with the change of the site over the same two windows.
Then look at the same days a year ago, so that a season does not pass for a result.
Leave out pages with too few clicks
Small numbers swing by chance. A page that went from 6 to 9 clicks rose 50%, and that says nothing. When both windows hold fewer than 20 clicks, give the numbers and no percentage.
Read the position and the click rate as well as the clicks. A new title usually shows first in the click rate, at about the same position. A change to the content usually shows in the position.
Say what moved beside the change, not why
Search results move for many reasons at once: Google's updates, other sites, the season, the demand. A before and after comparison shows what moved next to your change. It cannot prove that the change caused it.
Write it that way in a report. Name the clicks before and after the page went live, and how far the whole site moved in the same days.
Read it in Impact Reports
Impact Reports covers the last 28 days, 90 days or 180 days, against the days before and the same days a year ago. It lists the fixes a crawl confirmed, the ones that came back and each rewritten page.
For each page that AI Page Rewriter rewrote, the clicks are for the 28 days before and the 28 days after the page went live. The page's change stands beside the site's change. AI Page Rewriter is on Business and up.
A page shows Waiting until its days are complete, and Too few clicks under 20 clicks in both windows. It shows Measured once it can be judged, or Not measurable when the numbers cannot be compared.
Download this report gives a PDF or Excel on every plan, with your logo and name on Starter and up: the fixes confirmed, the pages rewritten and the clicks before and after, ready to send.